Last Friday, January 7, Beyoncé’s eldest daughter celebrated her first birthday. Baby Blue Ivy is 10 years old. The star birthday girl, already by tradition, was publicly congratulated by her grandmother, 68-year-old Tina Knowles-Lawson. The woman published a joint picture with her granddaughter, which, however, was criticized instead of compliments.

Why is Blue Ivy style criticized?
In the photo, the girl poses in a strict manner, which slightly shocked the users. “At 10, she looks at all 20”, “An example of how not to dress a child”, and “They simply deprive her of her childhood,” they write in the comments. Even Tina herself notes that baby Blue is already acting like an adult. “Sometimes I forget that she is so young,” says the grandmother of the birthday girl in a congratulatory post.

Many believe that Beyoncé initiates her daughter into the adult world too early. Recall that at the age of 10, the baby managed to voice a children’s audiobook, star in five videos and receive a Grammy music award for one of them, and also launch her clothing line. But we will not conceal a sin, all these merits went to her not without the help of an eminent mother.

Baby Blue from childhood gets what many of us can only dream of. Star hangouts, a closet full of luxury clothes, billions on a personal account, and bright exits on the red carpet on a par with adults. Needless to say, she has a personal stylist and chef, as well as security that accompanies her to a school worth 30 thousand dollars a year.
Users concluded that adult clothes, makeup, and manicures are not something that should be taught to a 10-year-old child. “Children should remain children,” they say in the comments. Many believe that the “adult” lifestyle at such an early age can negatively affect the girl. I want to believe they are wrong. However, this is often exactly what happens.

What do you think, is Beyoncé doing the right thing? Is it too early for little Blue to grow up? Write in the comments!